Score: 9

"I liked it less than the others"

submission: The Masterpiece For Linerider

date: August 26, 2008

I liked it all except for the guitar which didn't fit with the ambient and mysterious theme. It would have been good in a different song but not this one. The guitar was good at a couple of points but I think took away more than it gave. Good as always. Keep me updated on new stuff, I always love to hear it.

Score: 10

"You already know pretty much what I think"

submission: Reflecting Sunrise - Mjattie

date: August 26, 2008

I loved it as usual. It had a very nice feel to it with a good serene sounding start and a nice psy-ish sounding middle/ending. You should be proud of this one as much as any of the others, it is a really great song. I 5'd it and downloaded it. Very compelling melody once again.

Score: 10

"I agree with the others"

submission: Happy Madness Times - Mjattie

date: August 26, 2008

I really liked the instruments in general. It sounded very polished like most of your songs. The drums and violin were phenomenal. At about 38 seconds into the song, there seemed to be an odd stuttering kind of sound, like the song was walking and then stumbled a little. Bad metaphor, but it's what I thought of when I heard it. The melody had an odd sound which was both highly appealing and slightly offputting. It looped pretty well too. The more I listen to it, the more I like it. Thanks for keeping up all the awesome music. Thanks again and as usual for the pm. I appreciate the effort you put into your music, keep it up.

Score: 10

"Not that jazzy"

submission: Jazzy Lounge Song - Mjattie

date: August 26, 2008

I liked it, the piano had a nice ring to it. The whole thing sounded very polished and nice, it wasn't that jazzy though. It seemed more on the side of classical most of the time. Good job, good melody, good drums, good piano, very good overall. You are right to be proud of this. I agree that it is nice background music. I can imagine this being used as the background music of some rpg at some sort of shrine or the woods or something. It is a great song.

Score: 10

"Loved it"

submission: A Silver Kiss - Remastered

date: August 17, 2008

Great as usual, even better than the original which was mindblowing to begin with. 5/5

Score: 10

"I thought it was good"

submission: The dark light - Mjattie

date: August 17, 2008

It was certainly good, it was just seemed a bit random at times. No real patterns or repetitions beyond the basic melody. It was good but seemed a little uncontrolled. Whatever, 5/5

Score: 10

"Very Good"

submission: Forgotten Memories - Mjattie

date: August 17, 2008

I thought that at times it seemed like you were still trying to stick to your normal mellow melodic tunes rather than fully go out and do a full fledged trance or dance song. I think that the whole bass too loud/too quiet thing was that parts of the bass were too quiet while others were too loud. It was not really your best at all, but I think that you could really do well in this kind of thing with some more practice. I thought that at times there seemed to be an underlying static sound in the background which I didn't really like so much. It all seemed too low pitched for normal trance stuff. Then again, I am no expert in the making or specifics of electronic music, just a fan, so I may be wrong. Either way, that's my opinion for what it's worth. I gave it a 5.

Score: 10

"Very well done, once again"

submission: Forgotten Tears - Mjattie

date: August 17, 2008

You are really talented in coming up with new, original, and overall fantastic melodies. This one has a very calming one with a sort of subtle yet powerful influence upon the listener. It is really amazing how you keep on coming up with more and more melodies while never faltering in your unerring history of excellence. That being said, I gave it a 10, a 5, downloaded it, and almost favorited it, but decided not to considering how much great stuff you will probably come out with later. Good job, and as always, thanks for the pm.

Score: 9

"One of the weirdest"

submission: Back to the bush

date: August 17, 2008

That was one of the weirdest songs I've heard in a while, it was actually pretty good despite all the useless little sound effects you added.

Score: 10

"almost a 9"

submission: Swete Sowte Swate - Mjattie

date: July 19, 2008

I didn't think it was quite there at a 10. It was closer to a 10 than to a 9 so I gave it a 10. Just barely. I thought lost was better (I love it just as much as I listen to it for maybe the 37'th time) but this was decent. Not much to say.